Research courtesy of Sgt. John Campbell
1926–1945
Chief John J. Koestner
1945–1953
Chief George G. Marshall
1953–1960
Chief Carlton J. Brower
1950–1977
Chief George Brugnolli
- Varnal Lake
- James Fulton
- Harold Johanson
- Harry Buehlmeir
1977–1989
Chief William Ennis
- Joseph Ennis
- Lloyd Elliot
1989–1995
Chief Jack Sprengel
- Sgt. Walter Walla
- Sgt. James Davis
- Capt. Peter McHale
- Officer Jean Soffel
- Officer Joseph Hanlon
- Officer Stephan Kopp
- Officer Wesley Gross
1995–2002
Chief Edgar Brennen
- Det. Lt. Donald Proscia
- Capt. John Rohack
- Sgt. George P. Hall
- Officer John Mull
- Officer Walter R. Breyer
- Officer Robert M. Grobel
- Capt. Joseph J. Maggio
- Officer Peter L. Cimelli
- Officer Thomas Tank
2002–2010
Chief Rhynie J. Emanuel
- Sgt. Anthony J. Lomoriello
- Officer James Pricolo
- Officer Joseph R. Inganamort
- Sgt. George Hecker
- Officer Bruce R. Tucker
- Det. Lt. Harold S. Bonsper
- Sgt. Robert Franke
- Lt. Joseph Lardinelli
- Sgt. Leonard Haak
- Sgt. John Accardi
- Sgt. Thomas McMahon
2011–2014
Chief Frank Florio
- Sgt. Kevin Smith
- Lt. Michael Oslacky
- Officer Richard Filipow
- Officer John Sheridan
- Lt. Richard Zdanowicz
2017–2025
Chief William Wicker
- Officer Salvator Silla
- Sgt. Kevin Doyle
- Sgt. John H. Campbell
- Sgt. Derek E. Kahill
- Capt. Victor Egg
2025–Present
Chief David Gangemi
- Det. Sgt. Marc Fedorchak
- Anthony Foschino
- Sgt. Michael Bartlett
- Sgt. Richard Liguori
- Officer Joseph Lardineli
- Lt. Joseph Maino
- Officer Thomas Madden
- Officer Jeffry Peters
- Lt. Roger Pressburger
- Sgt. Kyle Costa
- Officer Brennen Page
- Officer Ian Paulic
- Sgt. Glenn Zeszotarski
- Officer Daniel O'Leary
- Sgt. Paul Kochansky
- Officer Stephen Viscito
- Det. Sgt. Joseph Maddolin
- Sgt. Nicholas Ostuni
- Officer Andrew Hartophilis
- Officer Frank Stefano
- Officer Kevin Bernal
- Officer Thomas Damato
- Officer Michael Bahadourian
- Officer Joseph Carr
- Officer John Mullins
- Officer Luke Fisher
- Officer Connor Olsen
- Officer Nico Del Terzo
- Officer Ryan Briggs
